A Stolen Laptop’s Windows Hello PIN Can Be Cracked in 40 Hours, Researchers Show
A four-digit Windows Hello PIN is safe only as long as the laptop locks out a thief after a few wrong guesses. Researchers have now shown how to switch that lockout off.
A team from Technische Universität Berlin found a way to reset the counter of wrong PIN attempts on Windows laptops and desktops that use a firmware TPM, the security chip function built into modern AMD and Intel processors. With the counter reset after every few guesses, their automated setup found a four-digit Windows Hello PIN in 40 hours instead of 69 days. A six-digit BitLocker startup PIN, the default minimum, fell in 20 days instead of 19 years.
The paper, “Hello Again“, is being presented this week at the ACM CCS security conference in The Hague. When we published, it had been picked up on Hacker News and on Mastodon, but we found no reports from major outlets.
The attack needs the computer in hand, a screwdriver and days of time, so it’s a stolen-laptop problem, not a remote one. The fix for most people is a longer PIN.
How the Attack Works
Windows lets you sign in with a PIN as short as four digits because the TPM, not Windows, is supposed to stop anyone from guessing it. After five wrong tries Windows makes you restart, and after enough failures the TPM itself locks the PIN for a while. Guessing 10,000 combinations that way takes months.
The weak spot is where a firmware TPM keeps its memory. It has no storage of its own, so it saves its state, including the count of wrong guesses, to the same flash chip that holds the computer’s firmware. That copy is encrypted, so an attacker can’t edit it. They can copy it, though, and later put the old copy back. The count of wrong guesses then goes back to where it was.
Newer computers are meant to stop exactly that with a feature called RPMC (replay protected monotonic counters): the flash chip keeps a counter of its own that only goes up, so an old copy no longer matches. The researchers found three ways around it:
- Winbond flash chips give away the secret key that protects their counter when the attacker briefly disturbs the chip’s power supply (voltage glitching). With the key, the attacker can fake the counter. Winbond makes more than a quarter of these chips.
- AMD processors don’t check whether the counter actually went up. A small board wired between the processor and the flash chip can quietly block the update.
- AMD computers without RPMC flash had no protection at all: on two AMD desktops, writing an old firmware image back to the chip reset the lockout.
For the brute force itself, the researchers connected that board plus a keyboard-and-screen controller to the laptop. Software reads the login screen, types PINs, reboots when Windows asks, and puts the old copy back during each reboot.
A cracked PIN gives more than access to the desktop. The researchers point out that it also unlocks the keys Windows keeps tied to that device and company single sign-on that relies on Windows Hello. Microsoft’s own fTPM, Pluton, was affected on AMD systems in the same way as AMD’s.
Which Computers Are Affected
The researchers tested nine computers from 2015 to 2025, including a Lenovo ThinkPad T15 Gen 2, a Framework Laptop 13, an HP OmniBook 3 and an Acer Aspire 14 AI, the last two sold as Copilot+ PCs. By their assessment:
- Computers that use Winbond RPMC flash are open to the key-leak route, whatever the processor. They demonstrated the BitLocker attack on an Intel laptop this way.
- AMD computers with RPMC flash are open to the blocked-update route until AMD ships a firmware fix.
- AMD computers without RPMC flash accept an old firmware copy outright.
- Intel computers in their tests rejected a plain old copy; the risk there comes from the flash chip.
You can’t easily see which flash chip your laptop has. On AMD machines running Linux, the fwupdmgr security command shows an “AMD SPI Replay protections” line that tells you whether RPMC is in use. For Intel, the researchers know of no such check short of opening the device.
What Microsoft, AMD and Winbond Said
The researchers reported the problem to Winbond in January 2025 and again, with the key leak, in April 2026. Winbond told them its engineers are evaluating it, possibly with a new chip revision, but gave no fix or date.
AMD heard about the blocked-update flaw in February 2026, saw the full Windows Hello attack in April and got two proposed firmware fixes in September. According to the paper, AMD acknowledged the report but hasn’t given a technical assessment or committed to a fix.
Microsoft received the Windows Hello attack in April 2026 and rated it “moderate severity”, a defence-in-depth issue below the bar for an immediate update. It issued no CVE. It did commit to raising its recommended minimum Windows Hello PIN length to six digits, and, the researchers write, plans to say more once that fix ships. The BitLocker part was reported separately in September and is handled by another Microsoft team.
None of the vulnerabilities in the firmware or the flash chips had been fixed when the paper was written. We’ve asked Microsoft, AMD and Winbond for comment and will update this article with their replies.
Should You Worry?
Only if someone could get your computer for days. The attacker has to open the case, attach hardware to the flash chip and keep the machine running through thousands of reboots. That rules out the casual thief who wants to resell the laptop. It matters for people whose data is worth that effort: journalists, lawyers, company laptops with access to internal systems, anyone a determined adversary might target.
The researchers also found that the lockout rules on real laptops don’t match Microsoft’s documentation. Some machines made users wait two hours, not ten minutes, after too many wrong guesses. That slows ordinary guessing but does nothing against the rollback, which skips the wait entirely.
What You Can Do
The cheapest defence is a longer PIN. The researchers’ own figures show how fast the window closes: a six-digit Windows Hello PIN takes up to 168 days with their attack, an eight-digit BitLocker PIN up to six years.
- Make your Windows Hello PIN longer, or add letters. Go to Settings > Accounts > Sign-in options > PIN (Windows Hello) > Change PIN. Use at least six digits, better eight or more, or tick “Include letters and symbols”. Every letter you add multiplies the number of combinations.
- If you use a BitLocker startup PIN, make it eight digits or longer. Administrators can allow letters in it with the “Allow enhanced PINs for startup” policy. Most home PCs with device encryption don’t ask for a startup PIN at all; on those, the Windows sign-in screen is what stands between a thief and your files, so the Hello PIN is the one to fix.
- If a laptop goes missing, act fast. The attack takes hours to days. Remove the device from your Microsoft account, sign out of your other accounts on it and change passwords for anything it stayed signed in to.
- Companies can set a minimum PIN length and require letters through the Windows Hello for Business policies, without waiting for Microsoft’s new default.
The researchers would rather Windows lock the PIN for good after 32 wrong tries, as iPhones do with their passcode. Microsoft hasn’t said whether it will.
Our Mission
We believe security online security matters and its our mission to make it a safer place.