VPN technology has become indispensable in the interconnected world of 2023. Individuals and corporations alike are using VPNs to surf the web and conduct business in a more secure manner. But this tool is also used for illegal activities, bypassing geo-blocks, and other unethical activities.
I won’t discuss the legality and illegality of VPN usage in this article. I’ve already talked about that in another post, so check it out!
Instead, I’ll focus on the ethical question of VPN usage. When is it ethical to use it and when is it not? Do we throw the baby out with the bathwater or accept the compromises?
Let’s explore it!
There are clear legitimate and ethical reasons for using a VPN, such as:
A VPN’s foremost usage is to enhance your privacy and protect your private data from being accessed by unknown parties.
By creating a data tunnel between your internet connection and the VPN server, you can hide your:
No one has a de facto right to know these things about you, and it’s entirely ethical to want to hide them. After all, it’s your personal life and private data, and these aren’t public properties.
Privacy protection becomes even more important for individuals living under abusive regimes, journalists going to high-risk countries, or defectors.
Securing Personal Data on Public Networks
Virtual Private Networks can help secure your connection when using public Wi-Fi networks. The data tunnel I mentioned earlier is also encrypted, which means that all the transit data is indecipherable to threat actors.
Public Wi-Fi networks are infamous for the high risk of man-in-the-middle attacks or eavesdropping attacks. A hacker could “listen in” on your connection and find out private information like name, banking data, login credentials, and more.
By using a good VPN, you encrypt the normally unencrypted Wi-Fi connection so that threat actors can’t compromise it.
While not all identity theft breaches are in your control, Wi-Fi networks are. And VPNs are the best way to protect yourself against them.
This is also a clear case of ethical usage because you’re protecting yourself against potential attackers who want to steal from you.
This one is a bit of a grey area. Let me explain:
Using a VPN to bypass state-imposed restrictions when you live under an abusive regime is arguably an ethical usage of VPNs. In my view, it falls under the “self-protection” prerogative.
No one should assume or justify non-action when your rights are taken away one by one, and as such, VPNs are a tool for liberation.
This is the grey area I was talking about. That’s because in most cases, geo-blocks on streaming services happen because of licensing agreements, legitimate copyright regulations, regulatory requirements, and other legitimate interests.
By using a VPN, you’re effectively breaking the Terms of Service of the streaming company and bypassing all of the above.
Is it legal? Yes, in the vast majority of cases. There isn’t any law stopping you from using a VPN to access geo-blocked content on streaming services.
Of course, if the streaming provider finds out, they may terminate their account and they’d be justified in doing so.
But is it unethical? That’s a more nuanced discussion but in short, I believe it is unethical only if you breach copyright regulations, just like it’s unethical to pirate content from P2P platforms.
VPNs, just like any other technology, can be misused and utilized for unethical and/or illegal activities. These may include:
A VPN will hide your traces and anonymize you, effectively helping you escape the consequences of your actions. However, while these actions are inexcusable, I would still argue that VPNs are not unethical or illegal by themselves.
Only the ways you use them can be unethical and illegal. Someone might use VPNs to engage in cybercrime, while someone will use the technology to protect themselves from cyber-criminals.
Impact on Cybersecurity Landscape
It’s also true that VPNs make it harder for law enforcement and cybersecurity experts to identify and track down threat actors, especially if the VPN providers have no-log policies in effect.
But that may be a compromise we have to do in order to preserve the many benefits provided by VPN services. Just think about it:
There are many such examples, and the idea is that VPNs are not intended for illegal activities or unethical use.
There’s no question that some users, many even, engage in illegal activities or unethical practices. And that’s a bad thing. But we can’t really ban VPNs and throw the baby out with the bathwater since most of its users aren’t doing anything illegal or unethical.
It’s worthwhile to look at what VPN users vs. non-VPN users think regarding data privacy, the internet, and other technol0gy-related topics. This will help us figure out if VPN users are uniformly more preoccupied with their privacy and anonymity.
The same Global World Index study gives us the answer:
It looks like there isn’t a big difference between VPN users and non-VPN users in how they feel about data privacy and anonymity.
Sure, more VPN users feel stronger about privacy and anonymity but the difference is only a few points.
A more relevant statistic shows us the usage motivations per country. It seems that only the users in France, Austria, Germany, Canada, Portugal, the UK, Switzerland, and Denmark are motivated by remaining anonymous when browsing.
Users in 33 other countries are mostly motivated by accessing better entertainment content online, while only the users in the UAE mostly use VPNs to communicate with their friends and family abroad.
So, the main motivation of VPN users worldwide (as of 2018) is to access better entertainment, likely by bypassing geo-restrictions imposed by streaming services.
And, as I’ve already said, this should only be considered unethical if the users are breaking copyright regulations by bypassing said geo-blocks.
When it comes to licenses, red-tape, and conflicts between multiple license holders to certain entertainment media on these streaming platforms, many say that it’s not the user’s fault or problem.
In the end, you shouldn’t worry about the ethics of VPN usage as long as you don’t:
If you’re a regular user, then you likely want to protect your online identity, keep your sensitive data private, and defend yourself against threat actors.
Even if you have no reasons to hide anything, it’s your right to uphold your privacy online. You don’t need a good reason to hide your activities online.
VPNs are now more relevant than ever before with the emergence of cybercrime-as-a-service and the increasing number of cyberattacks!
Global World Index – VPN Users Around the World